Popular searches

Marquise
Evelyn
Ariel
Tinkerbell Inspired Wedding Set
Nova

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $200 away from free shipping.
Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

New
Engagement Rings
Wedding Rings
Jewelry
Diamonds
About Us

Made to Order (MTO) Engagement Rings 218

Most Popular Engagement Ring Collections

Nova
Kayla
Stephanie
Lindsey
Caraline
Ariel

Filters

Availability
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Shape
More options
Center Stone Type
Ring Design
Ring Name
More options
Care Level
View 218 items
 
Made to Order

Jane Cushion

$2,199.00
Kelsey Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Kelsey Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kelsey Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kelsey Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Kelsey Oval

$2,099.00
 
Made to Order

Rei Oval

$2,099.00
 
Made to Order

Sunnie Oval

$2,499.00
 
Made to Order

Sage Marquise

$1,999.00
Leilani Radiant Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Leilani Radiant Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Radiant Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Radiant Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Radiant Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Radiant Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Leilani Radiant

$2,699.00
Gracie Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Gracie Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Gracie Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Gracie Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Gracie Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Gracie Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Gracie Oval

$1,699.00
Kaia Marquise Pavé Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Kaia Marquise Pavé Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kaia Marquise Pavé Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kaia Marquise Pavé Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kaia Marquise Pavé Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kaia Marquise Pavé Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Kaia Marquise Pavé

$3,099.00
Brandi Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Brandi Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Brandi Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Brandi Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Brandi Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Brandi Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Brandi Oval

$2,199.00
Leilani Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Leilani Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Leilani Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Leilani Heart

$2,699.00
 
Made to Order

Meghan Oval

$1,799.00
Amber Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Amber Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Amber Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Amber Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Amber Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Amber Oval Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Amber Oval

$1,999.00
Isabela Cushion Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Isabela Cushion Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Isabela Cushion Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Isabela Cushion Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Isabela Cushion

$2,399.00
Kelsey Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Kelsey Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kelsey Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Kelsey Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Kelsey Emerald

$2,099.00
Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Toi et Moi Kayla High Polish

$1,699.00
 
Made to Order

Victoria Pear High Polish

$1,299.00
Caraline Cushion High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
Caraline Cushion High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Caraline Cushion High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Caraline Cushion High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Caraline Cushion High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Caraline Cushion High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Caraline Cushion High Polish

$1,199.00
1.6mm Angela Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
1.6mm Angela Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Angela Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Angela Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Angela Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Angela Emerald Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Angela Emerald

$2,399.00
1.6mm Nova Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
1.6mm Nova Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Nova Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Nova Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Nova Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Nova Heart Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Nova Heart

$1,699.00
1.8mm Gracie Pear Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
1.8mm Gracie Pear Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.8mm Gracie Pear Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.8mm Gracie Pear Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.8mm Gracie Pear Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.8mm Gracie Pear Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Petite Gracie Pear

$1,599.00
1.6mm Caraline Radiant High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
 
1.6mm Caraline Radiant High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Caraline Radiant High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Caraline Radiant High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Caraline Radiant High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
1.6mm Caraline Radiant High Polish Engagement Rings Princess Bride Diamonds
Made to Order

Caraline Radiant High Polish

$1,199.00
 
Made to Order

Ariel Emerald

$1,899.00
 
Made to Order

Kayla Marquise High Polish

$1,399.00
 
Made to Order

Rei Cushion

$2,099.00

Lifetime Warranty

All engagement rings and fine jewelry include lifetime cleanings, prong checks, and manufacturing defect coverage.

Free Resizing & Maintenance

Enjoy one free resizing and polishing or rhodium plating in the first year, plus lifetime prong tightening.

Fast + Secure Shipping

In-stock orders ship in 1–3 business days. Every package is tracked and insured for your protection.

Family-Owned Since 2006

Rooted in craftsmanship, community, and care, Princess Bride Diamonds is proudly family-run in Huntington Beach, CA.